Achieving idempotency with shell commands

Introduction

Ansible is powerful, but mastering it at enterprise scale requires understanding key concepts that aren't always straightforward, and having the right platform to implement them reliably. This comprehensive tutorial covers three critical areas that every Ansible developer should master:

• Idempotency: Writing playbooks that can be safely run multiple times
• Troubleshooting: Quickly diagnosing and fixing common playbook errors
• Advanced Loops: Implementing nested iteration patterns for complex automation

More importantly, we'll show you how Ascender Pro transforms these techniques from theory into production-ready automation with enterprise features that go far beyond what's possible with open-source Ansible or AWX.

---

Why Ascender Pro for Ansible development

The challenge with DIY Ansible

Many organizations start with command-line Ansible or upstream Ansible AWX, cobbling together custom scripts and manual processes. These approaches often lack:

• Stability: Breaking changes between AWX versions disrupt production
• Visibility: No centralized view of what automation is running and when
• Compliance: Limited audit trails and reporting capabilities
• Support: No commercial backing when critical automation fails

What makes Ascender Pro different

Ascender Pro is CIQ's commercially supported, enterprise-ready automation platform built downstream of Ansible AWX. It provides:

1. Stable, version-locked releases

Unlike AWX's rapid release cycle with frequent breaking changes, Ascender Pro focuses on stability and security. Your automation runs your company, so it needs to be reliable.

2. Enhanced observability and compliance

• Complete audit trails for every automation run
• Drift detection to maintain system states
• CVE and errata visibility for proactive security management
• Compliance reporting that auditors can access directly

3. Developer-friendly features

• Update revision on launch: Automatically sync Git repos before each run
• Detailed JSON output: Inspect every variable and result
• Visual workflow builder: Chain multiple playbooks with conditional logic
• Job output history: Review past runs with 90+ days of retention

4. Enterprise support and migration services

• Commercial support when you need it
• Migration assistance from AWX, Ansible Automation Platform, or custom solutions
• Indemnification and SLAs for peace of mind

How this tutorial leverages Ascender Pro

Throughout this guide, we'll show you not just how to write better Ansible playbooks, but how to develop, test, and deploy them using Ascender Pro's enterprise features that make your automation reliable at scale.

In this first blog post of our four-part series, we’ll be covering how to achieve idempotency with shell commands.

Part 1: What is idempotency?

Idempotency means you can run a playbook multiple times and it will only make changes when necessary. Ansible's built-in modules are idempotent by design, but shell commands present a challenge: they always report as "changed" even when they don't actually modify anything.

The problem with shell commands

Consider this simple example:

---
- name: Non-idempotent shell demo
  hosts: localhost
  gather_facts: false

  tasks:
    - name: Create a file using shell
      ansible.builtin.shell: |
        echo "I'm always hungry" > /tmp/test1.txt

Every time you run this playbook, Ansible reports it as "changed" even if the file already exists with the exact same content. This makes it difficult to know when real changes occur.

Solution 1: Use idempotent modules when possible

The best approach is to use Ansible's built-in modules instead of shell commands:

- name: Create a file idempotently
  ansible.builtin.copy:
    content: "I'm always hungry"
    dest: /tmp/test1.txt

This will only report "changed" when the file is actually created or modified.

Solution 2: Implement idempotency with register and changed_when

When you must use shell commands, you can implement idempotency using register and changed_when:

- name: Delete a file with proper change detection
  ansible.builtin.shell: rm -fv /tmp/test1.txt
  register: remove_check
  changed_when: "'removed' in remove_check.stdout"

How this works:

1. register captures the command output into a variable
2. changed_when evaluates a condition to determine if a change occurred
3. Only when "removed" appears in the output does Ansible report "changed"

Ascender Pro advantage: Change tracking and reporting

In Ascender Pro's job output, you can immediately see:

• Which tasks reported "changed" vs "ok" with color-coded visual indicators (orange vs. green)
• Detailed output showing exactly what changed
• Historical comparison across runs to identify patterns

Navigate to Jobs → [Your Job] → Output to see:

• Task-level status indicators
• Complete stdout/stderr capture
• Timestamp of changes for compliance reporting

For compliance teams, this automatic change logging means you can prove:

• What automation ran
• When it ran
• What it changed (or didn't change)
• Who authorized the run

All without writing a single line of extra logging code.

Working with stdout and stdout_lines

The register parameter captures output in two formats:

• stdout: Single string containing all output
• stdout_lines: List of strings, one per line (easier to iterate over)

Example:

- name: Get list of users
  ansible.builtin.shell: cut -d: -f1 /etc/passwd
  register: users
  changed_when: false  # This task never changes anything

- name: Display user list
  ansible.builtin.debug:
    var: users.stdout_lines

Controlling failure conditions with failed_when

You can also control when a task should fail:

- name: Check if file exists
  ansible.builtin.shell: ls /tmp/test1.txt
  register: file_check
  failed_when: false
  changed_when: false

The rc (return code) is 0 for success, non-zero for errors. This example allows both success and "file not found" without failing.

Handling expected failures with ignore_errors

Sometimes you want to note a failure but continue processing:

- name: Attempt to remove file (logs failure but continues)
  ansible.builtin.shell: rm -v /tmp/test2.txt
  register: remove_check
  changed_when: "'removed' in remove_check.stdout"
  ignore_errors: true

With ignore_errors: true, the playbook continues even if the task fails, but the failure is still recorded.

Ascender Pro advantage: Visual job status and alerts

When tasks fail (or succeed), Ascender Pro provides:

Real-time job monitoring:

• Dashboard showing all running jobs
• Color-coded status (green/orange/red) for quick scanning
• Drill-down into specific task failures

Automated alerting:

• Webhook integrations for Slack, PagerDuty, etc.
• Scheduled reports on automation health

Historical analysis:

• Track success/failure rates over time
• Identify flaky playbooks that need attention
• Audit trail showing who ran what and when

Compare this to command-line Ansible or AWX where you need to build custom logging and notification systems.

Ascender Pro’s detailed job output shows exactly which tasks changed and which didn’t. Automatic compliance logging proves what your automation did and didn’t change. No extra code required.

Explore Ascender Pro

Best practices for idempotency

1. Always prefer built-in modules over shell/command when possible
2. Use changed_when: false for tasks that only gather information
3. Capture output with register before evaluating change state
4. Test your logic by running playbooks multiple times
5. Be specific with conditions - don't use overly broad matching
6. Document your logic - future maintainers will thank you

Complete idempotent example

---
- name: Idempotent shell script demonstration
  hosts: target_host
  gather_facts: false

  tasks:
    - name: Create a dummy file
      ansible.builtin.copy:
        content: "I'm always hungry"
        dest: /tmp/test1.txt

    - name: Delete the dummy file (idempotently)
      ansible.builtin.shell: rm -fv /tmp/test1.txt
      register: remove_check
      changed_when: "'removed' in remove_check.stdout"
      failed_when: false

    - name: Display removal status
      ansible.builtin.debug:
        msg: "File was {{ 'removed' if 'removed' in remove_check.stdout else 'not present' }}"

Next steps

We’ve discussed several critical Ansible development patterns that separate functional automation from production-ready infrastructure management. But knowing the techniques are only half the battle.

Are you ready to transform your Ansible automation? Download the Ascender Pro Solution Brief to see how enterprise features make idempotency, debugging, and complex workflows reliable at scale.